Our Facebook group has a long-running Neil joke, to the extent that he features in one of the questions you answer to join. Halloween production could save a fortune on special effects by just flashing up that question instead of Neil hovering in the background and Neil doing the socials...
First, last week’s unfinished business. I wasn’t particularly surprised that Shaun left, despite how hard he was trying. The gap between him and the others was getting wider. However, Jaime being back in the dance-off was more worrying, although her leaderboard position hadn’t helped. As for Shirley voting to save Shaun… I would love two minutes inside that woman’s brain.
Onto Halloween, where everyone had apparently received slightly different instructions about how much Halloween to bring.
Anton’s costume immediately prompted Vanessa to ask, “Is Anton a dead Liberace?” Almost simultaneously, Tara offered “midlife crisis Liberace” and I think somewhere between the two lies the answer. Also, I did spend part of the evening wishing someone had matched the red of Emma's lipstick to her dress a little more closely. Yes, this is the level of scrutiny available here. You’re welcome.
I’m also becoming more comfortable with the presenting team. I respect that they’re still finding their feet, metaphorically speaking, and little in-jokes are starting to develop upstairs. Jojo and Jaime having their regular dance together is becoming a thing, and I like it. There’s some warmth and familiarity creeping in.
But, judging by the Facebook, Digital Spy and Reddit discussions I’ve been reading, the viewing public remains firmly split over the new setup. I’m happy to give them time. My reservations about this particular show were more to do with the music and choreography. Something felt off, and I couldn’t quite put my finger on it.
We do need a name for upstairs, though, or shall it forever be The Clauditorium?
༻❁༺
Graeme and Lauren’s Samba didn’t help shake that feeling. There were too many repeated movements for me, and the changes in rhythm made it feel disjointed. He never quite seemed to settle into it. Ali said this was the first week she’d been disappointed by him and wanted him back in ballroom; Tara thought it was his weakest dance yet. After some lovely performances over the past few weeks, this was a bit of a wobble.
Delta and Kai certainly looked the part as Morticia and Gomez. I also noticed, during their rehearsal session that Kai has a tattoo sleeve on his right arm! How have I never seen this before? There was also considerable appreciation in the group for the moustache. Their Viennese Waltz was beautifully danced. I didn’t spot anything going wrong, there was a fleckerl, and the judges were suitably appreciative. I was… a bit bored. Sorry. I can recognise that something is technically good without wanting to watch it again immediately. Disco Delta remains much more my thing.
Ali made a good point about the stronger dancers still needing proper feedback on their footwork, even when everything looks beautiful. This would also be easier for those of us at home to assess if the camera pulled back and the dry ice didn’t occasionally turn the floor into a missing persons investigation.
Tabby and Mark’s Quickstep was cute, and I’m increasingly fond of their partnership. Unfortunately, she missed the leap in the promenade, and it seemed to unsettle her for the last few bars. There were some timing issues too but it was still cheerful and enjoyable. After last week’s dance, which had me practically climbing into the television, this wasn’t quite the follow-up I’d hoped for.
Then came John and Katya, with a LaDuca boots klaxon and enough latex to make me feel sweaty sitting on the sofa. Tara described the look as “BDSM meets Matrix”, which saves me several sentences. I’d been thinking that Katya seemed a little lost with John this year, without quite as many of her usual tricks, when she promptly produced a spinny floor lift (technical term, obvs). The Tango was good, but I’m still waiting for their partnership to properly click for me. Thirty-five put them second on the leaderboard; I wasn’t nearly as excited as that score suggests.
Bethany and Nancy’s Jive felt flat-footed, and whatever was supposed to happen at the end didn’t quite happen. There seemed to be another part to the trick that went missing, leaving a messy finish. Anton’s comments about the second half tiring and Craig’s observation about lethargy were in line with what I’d been seeing. The music didn’t help me either. Tara wondered whether the drumming was off; I couldn’t tell you exactly what the problem was, but the whole thing felt harder work than it should have.
And then Cach and Maddie arrived. The over-the-shoulder opening lift! Immediately, I was paying attention. I loved their Argentine Tango. It was intense, exciting, and the first dance of the evening that left me wanting more. Cach still needs a stronger, more upright posture. At times, I wanted him to stop coming down towards Maddie and let her reach up to him. But the performance had me completely. Last week I was talking about the little bits of his own style that keep appearing in his dancing; this week, I could see a potential finalist. Vanessa’s response was considerably louder: “NOW WE’RE TALKING.” Quite. Although Craig’s seven brought the volume straight back up again for different reasons.
Jaime and Carlos gave us a fun Salsa. There were a couple of stumbles and moments when she was off the beat, but I enjoyed it, and those heels deserve some acknowledgment along with the 'pot stirrer' move. Shirley is particularly exacting when someone attempts what I think of as her moves. I understand why she spots every detail, but a five felt harsh. Ali’s “FIVE, Shirley!!!??” represented a fair proportion of the group at that point.
Will and Dianne’s Couple’s Choice didn’t do much for me. The theatre setting immediately reminded me of Faye and Giovanni’s Sound of Music Charleston, which is probably an unfair comparison to have rattling around your head before a dance has even finished. I completely forgot that speciality dances are always choreographed by a specialist (shout out to Jake Leigh here) and, credit where it’s due, Debbi corrected me when I started talking about Dianne’s choreography. I'm still missing a bit of Dianne’s usual spark this series, though so I keep waiting for that moment when it all comes together for me. It must be incredibly hard to come back from maternity leave to a full-on schedule for Strictly though.
Lawrence and Jowita’s Tango had some good posture, and I liked the arm section. The slide also went down well in the group. A decent performance, although Ghostbusters again? There must be another Halloween song available somewhere. Have we checked the back of Dave Arch’s cupboard?
Then Dani and Nikita finally delivered the Halloween performance I’d been waiting for. They had absolutely received the acting memo with the expressions, the movements, the styling and the story all working together, and Dani’s improvement is becoming impossible to ignore. I bloody loved it. Before they’d even finished being discussed, I wanted to watch it again. There was a little error in the dance where Nikita slipped, and he acknowledged it when the judges pointed it out. Tara supplied the perfect interpretation of Dani’s mid-dance response: “nope, you’re not messing this” followed by a YOINK!
Vanessa reckoned Dani had saved Nikita and Halloween. Difficult to argue. Four eights, though? Piss right off, especially with last week’s ten for Delta still fresh in my memory. I’m aware they’re different dances, but the scores are supposed to help us make sense of the competition, and I was struggling with this.
Finally, Lacey and Vito gave us a proper Charleston. Fast, cheeky, packed with content, and performed by someone who looked as though she was actually enjoying herself. I felt that some of the lifts were a little stop-start, but they were ambitious and she committed to them. After weeks of me willing her to let go, it was lovely to see so much personality coming through. Last week’s little kick was a highlight; this week, we got a whole dance with that spirit. The revelation of her internal persona being called “Pat”, followed by her little speech about being late to the party, but finding it a nice party to be at, made me think we’re finally seeing her settle in. Four nines and the top of the leaderboard felt like a very good place to end the show.
TL;DR: Cach, Dani and Lacey were my favourites. Three dances I’d happily watch again, in a show where too much of the rest left me waiting to be properly entertained.
I don’t think I’m hunting for faults because things have changed. I’ve enjoyed plenty about this series, including some of those changes. But the music and choreography didn’t consistently hit the usual Halloween standard for me. The best routines showed exactly how good it could have been. Meanwhile, our weekly voting crisis continues: vote for your favourite performance, or protect someone you’re worried might disappear? Add a third place in the dance-off and that decision gets even more complicated.
༻❁༺